![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhUzNvaJBp-yc_-8pUDgbWJci3MGbcxswVmNWsst259b9vLB_LKTiaJbkj0BFQp_cnGwPrFBHXm5XTNSN4dUF4pXevIS12kTsJFYC0LMVrAesP_osUE6EI1BPuKNbG8ExEjh66jFoC-56o/s400/Baneth.jpg)
I'm not cerain why he used the term "Minus" for most of this list!! Interesting that it is somewhat different then the list in Parshas Mordechai.
A letter from R' Benet to R Tzvi Hirsch Berlin, the fsther of R Saul can be found here. - literary supplement No. 6 53-55 No. 9 140-141.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgfhlQYnP4-udc4AEsaS4BjhX_wzgPX82_ga79A-I77BWlOxnTXu6GV26fkdwRbMG19X2jSS1nDGcXl02_uSQ0VkzgvAlWIuZMCNEQRe6oj9opxdjfkZelBm6L21Ma_13NzmpIcyxFmZJU/s320/Benet1.jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhv034LY11-AL_YA5aolIDeYHM4WTodgiM-ry3BZOxNo8GSTnaT6qPM-hUZUEU9ZWQ9RT_ajdzB-en_qJ3beq0Q1C32rr6LHKoCTNMw5EN1Ftkfn_ZStjgRjdPEBIhocIKnOpSLTVE2OPg/s320/Benet2.jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhoxpC2MmBB0VZAbidD-Aaa-85y8fBiGNWMAvddeKKLdaTYyKzD7XiIQ1X8x5R3AVkismy0dQoUFWBzOrqIIpx4MR6Eie27Z3SmcJOHD9-pCIbJaO0FKgPl5UvGYBa_Oguu6jqVelgnYXQ/s320/Benet3.jpg)
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgU5cQibo1Tg1UVMvKiPGRhAlxLsKohglsqs4P4QTquAinifdyAvn3zbQps6rQsMshPP-brez7MGlGw5W32Rg2LoAbXZjh2rYmoMSRa2ZquwHBoTF4hZ3Ljt2dPH2pQPshq_Kpd-MAv03I/s320/Benet4.jpg)
On the publisher of this letter, Solomon Rosenthal - See YY Greenwald - Toldot Mishpachat Rosenthal (available at Hebrewbooks.org). [Update: I see now that this is the very same letter that appears in Parshas Mordechai - of course without credit to Orient.]
[In the same newspaper, I noticed a review of ShuT Chasam Sofer See Issue 15 pg. 247 of the PDF, and an article by Raphael Kirscheim on "Juden und Pesach" pg. 185 (202) of PDF.]
4 comments:
I don't know about chastising them for not giving credit to Orient.
See Feiner in The Jewish Enlightenment Notes to page 335-337 where he brings this letter from a sefer published in Budapest 1894
http://books.google.com/books?id=U6-HLZO-sI0C&dq=feiner+the+jewish+enlightenment&printsec=frontcover&source=bl&ots=NcfGIgYSff&sig=TKHI7q4nCtSzVzppATf1b8QdXyI&hl=en&ei=swvaSejAIdqIlAe0spTODA&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1#PPA425,M1
Alright, so theyt didn't ptovide proper attribution to Shai LaMoreh which quotes Rosenthal same story but I will update the post,
Thanks,
Wolf
I didn't mean to jump on you- I was only pointing it out.
A side oddity is why Feiner says it was printed in '94 when it was in '95, though I guess thats beter than Talya Fishman who when she quotes it says it was '91.
Post a Comment