Tuesday, December 16, 2008

Comment to letter in recent Yerushaseinu

I was very surprised that the last letter in Yerushaseinu 3:395 was published without response. Even if we ignore the nasty swipe at Dr Berliner, about whom he admits he knows nothing at all,who by all accounts was a ת"ח עצום שיראתו היה קודמת לחכמתו – this ironically, in a letter complaining of a supposed deficiency of respect towards great Rabbis. His complaint that Rabbis and Chokrim are mentioned side by side as if equals was already leveled against R' Dovid Tzvi Hoffmann, it is quite n order that a periodical dedicated to Minhag Ashkenaz should follow the precedent of האחרון בזמן והראשון במעלה של הגאוני אשכנז. (The oft-repeated and over-inflated complaint that they follow the academic protocol of leaving of title after first mention of a name is simply nonsensical, since as ought to be obvious to anyone with a modicum of good sense is a matte of style and has nothing to do with respect.)


More serious I think, is the attitude that insists that certain Rabbinic figures were so very great that any attempt to study and analyze their methodologies, sources, etc. is futile, or worse disrespectful.. First, nobody would protest against this mistaken notion as vehemently as these Rabbis themselves, as the Nodah B' Yehuda was fond of saying – דין (להקשות ולדון בדבריו) הניין לי ומסייע אין בו ממש. But even worse, is that the attitude that insists that great men are/were so very great that it is impossible to reach their level is the best way to stifle future greatness. See this very apt quote from G. K. Chesterton, and I once posted something similar from R Kook.
'

7 comments:

David Guttmann said...

see also the article in hakirah 5 by Rav Rabinovitch of Ma'ale Adumim

http://hakirah.org/Vol%205%20Rabinovitch.pdf

Lion of Zion said...

do you know if כרם חמד is available online? i found the early volumes on hebrewbooks.org, but i need vol. 9. todah.

wolf2191 said...

That sems to be the wrong Kerem Chemed - Goldenbergs Keren Chemed (and Bikkurei Haittim) is not online as far as I know but S might know more.

Lion of Zion said...

S doesn't know more and he also he alerted me that the kerem chemed on hebrewbooks is a different journal.

it seems that kiryat sefer doesn't work anymore on that site you had linked to

Wolf2191 said...

Yes, it seems to have been taken down. Its from Otzros HaTorah. I have all the files downloaded on my hard drive, so if you need something specific just email me.

Anonymous said...

It was extremely interesting for me to read this article. Thanks for it. I like such themes and anything connected to them. I definitely want to read a bit more soon.

Joan Swenson
escort top

Anonymous said...

It is certainly interesting for me to read that blog. Thanx for it. I like such themes and everything that is connected to this matter. I would like to read a bit more soon.

Bella Kuree
cavan escorts

 
Creative Commons License
Ishim V' Shittos by http://ishimshitos.blogspot.com/ is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.
Based on a work at ishimshitos.blogspot.com.