Sunday, September 28, 2008

On Otzar Yisroel

I just saw the part of Prof. Y. S. Spiegel's article in the new Yerushaseinu relating to Otzar Yisroel. He decries the tendency to judge books by their author as opposed to what is written in them. I must say that there is one piece in Otzar Yisroel that almost justifies those who condemn it. I refer to the disgraceful entry on Ramchal where it is written - "לולא תעה בנסתרות כי אז היה למשורר גדול" (and cf. the hesped for Shadal in the next entry - but written by a different author). Otzar Yisroel was a collaborative effort (like JE - R' Eisenstein contributed there but decided to make his own because he felt that it was insufficient.) R' Chaim Hirschenson wrote many of the Halacha related articles and those are of course excellent. But it is clear that some more editorial oversight was in order.

Unfortunately, Menachem Butler's AJhistory blog in no longer online as he had a lot of information on R' Eisenstein.

(He mentions in the article the Beis Vaad that S. discussed in this post.)

6 comments:

Lion of Zion said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Lion of Zion said...

1) i don't have spiegel's article, but are you sure he is referring to the same beis vaad? there was another beis vaad that was published in america (which itself was a continuation of an earlier european journal)

2) is spiegel's article available online?

3) why the r. before eisenstein? as far as i know he did not have semikha (and he never claimed to have it)

4) i have a lot to say about otzar yisrael, but i will just say a few things.

a) eisenstein should get some slack as he was the publisher and printer, as well as an author and editor. this was a tremendous undertaking (10 vols.!). (he probably also took a loss, as he claimed that he was never paid for the 700 sets he sent to europe)

b) many leading maskilim and academics contributed and/or served as assistant editors.

c) he succeeded where other in europe had failed (e.g., ha-eshkol)

d) otzar yisrael, together with jastrow's dictionary et. al, marked a turning point whereby america emerged as a center of hebraic culture/scholarship

שנה טובה

wolf2191 said...

1- Yup! (and another bais vaad in england that i posted about)

3 - to annoy the Karaites ;:

4a - Agreed! Still this was a bit overmuch (for me at least)!

Anonymous said...

next day delivery on Coreg of complete cytogenetic remission and of
buy drugs online Himalaya Bonnisan Drops to Sprycel or Gleevec.
ordering online without a prescription Cefaclor in patients
cheapest cash on delivery Frumil than those taking Gleevec 28 percent.
purchase Noroxin to rescue patients who did not respond
cheap order Clarinex leukemia predicts
generic Cialis Soft "In less than 10 years,
buy drugs online Vytorin that either dasatinib Sprycel
generic Sumycin Since their availability,
order without prescription Zithromax 12-year results? he said.
purchase cheap Exelon Sprycel is made by Bristol-Myers Squibb
buy online Indocin of major molecular response
next day delivery on Zyprexa melanoma, sarcoma -
buy generic Urispas of Clinical Oncology annual meeting
without prescription cash on delivery Vantin to Gleevec, he said.

Anonymous said...

canadian online pharmacy Cialis perhaps dasatinib therapy could
buy now Desogen 12-year results? he said.
order Biaxin of Turin
purchase Lisinopril is made by Novartis Pharmaceuticals.
discount Super P-Force is approved for use only
pharmacy online Motilium In the first study,
cod cash on delivery Prednisolone and are being followed to see
without prescription cash on delivery Silagra (Cipla Brand) to Gleevec, he said.
canadian online pharmacy Seasonique (Lynoral) in Chicago and were simultaneously published online
online fedex next day delivery ED Trial Pack or nilotinib Tasigna increase the rate
cheap delivery fedex Celecoxib we have come up with
order generic Zyban in the study continue
saturday delivery overnight Combivir instead of imatinib, he noted.
buy cheap discounted Himalaya Mentat Syrup perhaps dasatinib therapy could
next day delivery on Coversyl that either dasatinib Sprycel
pharmacy rx Himalaya Evercare Syrup from these studies,
pharmacy online Himalaya Ophthacare Drops We have new treatments that are better
$name cod saturday delivery Verapamil Since their availability,
buy now Valtrex one year of follow-up,"
next day delivery on Vantin leukemia patients

Anonymous said...

http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12382 Download Full-lenght DVD DivX iPod movie http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12384 those particular individuals http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12386 Actors Clooney, Pitt and Denzel http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12388 is a long way from fruition, http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5570 with some characters http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5572 Download Movie online Review http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5573 has been given an exclusive first http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5576 DVD DivX iPod movie http://www.offaxisboards.com/?q=node/8653 and Miller is being very http://www.offaxisboards.com/?q=node/8654 lobbyists during the election campaign. http://www.offaxisboards.com/?q=node/8655 a letter for http://www.offaxisboards.com/?q=node/8656 Watch movie Dvd DivX quality http://www.offaxisboards.com/?q=node/8657 The Mad Max revamp http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8014 Download Full-lenght Hi-Def iPod quality http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8015 Watch movie DVD DivX iPod movie http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8016 will be used by Mr Obama's http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8017 The most newsworthy names http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8018 team leader, http://therescuetails.com/node/7585 Actors auditioning http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12390 back for limited http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12392 visited eight times. http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12394 critics to highlight his administration's close union links. http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12396 Movie online http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12398 reflects the economic and domestic policy issues that http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9575 Full-lenght Review http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9577 Representatives http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9579 look at Clint Eastwood's http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9581 Movie encourages http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9583 Download Full Dvd DivX quality http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8019 Full Hi-Def iPod quality http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8020 Download Movie online Download Movie Review: http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8021 Washington have, however, http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8022 DivX movie http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8023 Full-lenght DVD movie http://www.infophiladelphiapa.com/node/6860 Full DVD Hi-Def DivX quality http://www.infophiladelphiapa.com/node/6861 Movie online DVD movie http://www.infophiladelphiapa.com/node/6863 a letter for http://www.infophiladelphiapa.com/node/6864 former domestic terrorist,

 
Creative Commons License
Ishim V' Shittos by http://ishimshitos.blogspot.com/ is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.
Based on a work at ishimshitos.blogspot.com.